Categories
ITOps

Scala vs Java performance – dynaTrace Analysis – Test 1 Fibonacci Sequence cont’

After some initial JVM monitoring yesterday, I looked at response times today. First thing I had to do was modify the respective classes slightly to get a non-constructor method doing all the work. This made it much easier to gather and chart the results within dynaTrace (though I did later find that there was a check box in dynaTrace to monitor constructors).

The tests today were again on 3 implementations of the Fibonacci sequence:

Java – see source

Scala Simple – see source

Scala Advanced – see source

Test environment info

I spent most of the day playing with dynaTraces monitoring and reporting tools so did not actually do that much testing. The tests I did run where quite short. The first being execution of the fib sequence returning the 10,000 value, the second stretching to 100,000. The charts below show the time results for each test, if more than one test was executed for an implementation in a 30 second cycle, the chart shows the average.

*Update 16-JUL: Retested on host machine (not running in VM) results where much more consistent despite having a number of other services operating at the same time. There are some clear results this time:

Java vs Scala vs Scala Adv - Fibonacci
Running on a host machine, the Java implementation has a slight performance edge over the Scala simple. The Scala advanced implementation is slower. These tests were to the 100,000th Fibonacci value

 

Test1Loop.NoAdv_JMVmon_1.000.000_HOST
Stretching the test the 1,000,000th Fibonacci value meant that Scala Adv overran the heap but the difference between Scala simple and Java was negligible

From the results it appears that the variations in response times are most likely caused by external factors (ie: OS or other services taking resouces, Garbage collections etc). I will really need to increase the sample size to get a better understanding of what is influencing response times.

Test1Loop.All3_ResponseTime_v10000
Fibonacci sequence to 10,000th value
Test1Loop.All3_ResponseTime_v100000
Fibonacci sequence to 100,000th value

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.